REVIEW: Whose Knowledge Counts? (From Warp Drive to Waka Huia) by Dr Pounamu Jade William Emery Aikman (Bridget Williams Books)

BWB Facebook

A bit of Star Trek, a lot of Māori wisdom and some pretty big questions about who gets to decide what's worth knowing.

Ever wondered why some people's knowledge is automatically treated as gospel, while others have to jump through hoops to prove they know what they're talking about? Why is Western, predominantly Pākehā knowledge often considered the gold standard, while Māori knowledge is sometimes treated as a nice cultural extra?

That's the question at the heart of this book. And it's a pretty timely question, given the political bunfight we've been having in Aotearoa over Te Tiriti, Māori rights and whose version of history gets to call the shots.

Don't be put off by the title. This isn't a dusty academic textbook or something you'll need a law degree to get through. It's an engaging, accessible read that tackles some big ideas without making you feel like you're sitting through a university lecture.

Aikman is an independent Māori scholar whose work explores Indigenous knowledge, sovereignty and criminal justice. His iwi affiliations include Ngāti Apakura, Ngāti Maniapoto, Ngāti Wairere, Ngāti Awa, Ngāi Te Rangi, Ngāti Uenukukōpako and Ngāti Tarāwhai. He's completed a PhD at the Australian National University, been a Fulbright Scholar at Harvard and worked on research into systemic bias in policing and inequalities affecting Māori.

In short, he knows his stuff, but thankfully he's not afraid to make it interesting.

What's Star Trek got to do with it?

One of the more entertaining features of the book is its use of Star Trek references. Yes, Star Trek – spaceships, warp drives, strange new worlds and all that jazz. Patrick Stewart, R.I.P. "You have earned your place among the stars.”

At first, you might wonder what Captain Kirk has to do with Māori knowledge. Quite a lot, actually.

Star Trek is all about encountering different civilisations, different cultures and different ways of understanding the universe. It provides a clever way of looking at how we react when we come across knowledge that doesn't fit our own way of thinking.

Why should one civilisation's understanding of the world automatically be considered better than another's?

The waka huia, traditionally used to hold precious treasures, provides the other half of the story. It represents the knowledge, whakapapa and taonga passed down through generations.

It's a clever contrast: from futuristic technology to the wisdom of our tūpuna. The message is that knowledge comes in many forms, and we shouldn't assume the cleverest ideas always come from a laboratory, university or government department.

Even Mr Spock might have to rethink a few things.

The problem with thinking Pākehā knowledge knows best

Aikman's main argument is that Western ways of thinking have become the default in New Zealand. They're generally regarded as rational, scientific and authoritative, while Māori knowledge is too often labelled traditional, cultural or somehow less sophisticated.

That didn't happen by accident. It's part of our colonial history and the way government, education, law and other institutions have developed.

Think about how we measure success. Economic growth, productivity, individual achievement and dollars and cents are often treated as the obvious measures of whether something is worthwhile.

But what about the health of a river? Is its value simply how much money it can generate, or should we also consider its whakapapa, mauri and importance to the people who have cared for it over generations?

What about community wellbeing, collective responsibility and the connection between people and whenua?

Aikman isn't saying Western science or economics are useless. Far from it. He's asking why they should automatically get the final say.

The problem isn't having different ways of understanding the world. It's allowing one group to decide which knowledge counts and which can be safely ignored.

And it's happening right under our noses, dammit!

The arguments become particularly relevant when you look at recent New Zealand politics.

Remember David Seymour's Treaty Principles Bill? Introduced in November 2024, it attempted to put three newly defined Treaty principles into law, based around Crown authority, equal rights and the recognition of Māori rights.

Seymour argued it would bring clarity and equality. But many Māori, Treaty experts and legal scholars saw it as an attempt to redefine the Treaty relationship without the agreement of Māori.

The concern was that the Crown's interpretation would effectively take precedence over the promises and protections contained in Te Tiriti, particularly tino rangatiratanga.

The response was the remarkable Hīkoi mō te Tiriti in November 2024. Thousands travelled from Te Hāpua in the Far North to Parliament, with tens of thousands gathering in Wellington on 19 November.

It was an extraordinary show of public opposition. This wasn't simply about one bill. It was about Māori making it very clear that their history, knowledge and understanding of Te Tiriti weren't going to be rewritten without a fight.

The bill was eventually defeated at its second reading in April 2025, by 112 votes to 11. Bet those 11 are feeling pretty insuperior!

Aikman's wider argument helps explain why this mattered. It was a contest over who gets to define the rules, whose knowledge is considered legitimate and who has the power to shape our future.

Another example is the Regulatory Standards Act 2025, which grew out of ACT's push for greater emphasis on economic efficiency, individual rights and regulatory discipline.

Aikman questions the worldview behind this approach. If government decisions are judged mainly through economic efficiency, individual property rights and cost-benefit calculations, where do tikanga, collective responsibilities and Māori understandings of wellbeing fit?

He uses the example of school lunch programmes to illustrate the issue. Should their value be judged simply by the dollars involved, or should we consider the wider benefits for children's health, education and wellbeing?

It's a good question. Sometimes the things that matter most don't fit neatly into a spreadsheet.

And that's the point: apparently neutral rules can still favour one particular way of thinking.

So where do we go from here?

Thankfully, Aikman isn't just having a moan about the state of the country. He's interested in where we go next.

His vision is an Aotearoa where Māori knowledge is recognised as living, relevant and valuable, rather than something wheeled out for a pōwhiri or the occasional government consultation.

That means giving mātauranga Māori, tikanga and Indigenous perspectives genuine influence in decisions affecting our communities and country.

Importantly, this isn't about replacing Pākehā knowledge with Māori knowledge. It's about making room for both, allowing different perspectives to contribute and challenging the assumption that there's only one right way of looking at the world.

There's a message here for all of us, particularly those of us who have grown up accepting that the established way of doing things must be the right way.

Maybe it isn't. Maybe we've been missing out on some pretty important knowledge because we haven't been prepared to listen.

Whose Knowledge Counts? is a clever, thought-provoking and very timely read. Aikman tackles some big subjects but manages to keep things accessible, with the Star Trek references adding a bit of fun to what could otherwise be fairly heavy material.

With the Treaty Principles Bill, the hīkoi and ongoing arguments about Māori rights and government policy, the book feels particularly relevant.

What I like most is that Aikman isn't simply looking backwards. They're encouraging us to think about the sort of country we want to become – one where different knowledge systems are respected and where Māori don't constantly have to prove the worth of what their tūpuna have known for generations.

At just under 200 pages, it's hardly a mission to Mars. You don't need a philosophy degree, a legal dictionary or a working knowledge of the entire Star Trek universe to enjoy it.

You might not agree with everything, but you'll certainly have a few things to think about. It's an eye-opener, a good conversation starter and a timely reminder that knowledge doesn't belong exclusively to the people sitting in Parliament or running the universities.

If we're clever enough to imagine warp drives and explore strange new worlds, surely we can manage to respect the knowledge that's been right here in Aotearoa for generations.

Dr Pounamu Jade William Emery Aikman (BWB)

Dr Pounamu Jade William Emery Aikman (Ngāti Apakura, Ngāti Maniapoto, Ngāti Wairere, Ngāti Awa, Ngāi Te Rangi, Ngāti Uenukukōpako, Ngāti Tarāwhai) is an independent scholar and writer exploring Indigenous sovereignty, mātauranga, criminal justice and the continuing reach of the settler state. A 2019 PhD graduate of The Australian National University and 2022 Fulbright Scholar at Harvard University, Aikman is the author of Terra in Our Mist: A Tūhoe Narrative of Indigenous Sovereignty and Settler-State Violence (ANU Press, 2026), a powerful examination of state violence against Ngāi Tūhoe that connects the 2007 Ruatoki raids to a much longer history of invasion, confiscation and colonial control. He also co-leads the Marsden-funded Tiaki Tāne project examining youth offending among young Māori men and was Te Herenga Waka Victoria University of Wellington’s 2025 Emerging Māori Writer in Residence.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

EVENT: VerbCrawl is back - For One Night Only - November 14th 2026!

Noelle McCarthy: from Grand to Stakes: An interview about mothers, memory, addiction and the books that help us make sense of ourselves

WOMAD: The World Of Words Programme is announced

INTERVIEW: Daniel Vernon Draws Prime Ministers, Fronts a Punk Band and Wrestles Māui

INTERVIEW: Asher Emanuel, Author of The Valley: Crime and Punishment in a New Zealand City (Bridget Williams Books)