REVIEW: The Beaded Curtain by Lloyd Jones (Massey University Press)
There is something fittingly deceptive about the title of Lloyd Jones’s remarkable The Beaded Curtain. A beaded curtain is a barrier, but hardly a solid one. It shifts with the air, momentarily revealing something outside before falling back into place. Jones remembers such curtains from New Zealand houses, letting in air while keeping out flies. Through them you caught incomplete views, afterwards wondering exactly what you had seen.
That becomes an elegant metaphor for memory, but also for
the larger questions at the heart of this unusual book: What does it mean to
witness something? Can we trust what we see? And what responsibility comes with
having seen it?
The Beaded Curtain
is part memoir, reportage, travelogue and philosophical quest. Yet it never
settles comfortably into any category. It feel like a constant channel switching, but the themes unite, despite the apparent differences. And to somehow keep the context, raise the metaphors and go beyond simply novelty to something more complex and poignant is superbly clever.
Jones is less interested in giving us an orderly
autobiography than in examining what has lodged in his consciousness and why:
birds, sheep, family, childhood, landscapes, Berlin, Hiroshima, war, extinction
and death. He described this in more detail at a book launch I recently attended. The Memorial to the Murdered Jews of Europe (better known as the Holocaust Memorial by most Berliners), opened in May 2005, located near the Brandenburg Gate is one of the city's most impressive sights and most disturbing. It's like a maze where no matter what path you take will deliver you to the same location. For wartime Jews, this was the camps.He saw it whilst on a writer's residency. It was incredibly moving, how people can be so cruel and yet we remain passive and aloof and neutral to the consequences. How do we witness such catastrophic events?
![]() |
| Ref to the official site of Berlin |
His writing method, switching between the complex and the simple, memory and profundity, is demonstrated brilliantly in the opening piece, Huia. It begins with nineteenth-century ornithologist Walter Buller remembering how, “without sound or warning of any kind, a huia came bounding along”, appearing so close that he cannot shoot. Instead he pauses to study the bird and admire its “noble bearing”, before the devastating conclusion: “before I shot him.”
Beauty, observation and violence suddenly sit inside the same encounter. The huia has been seen, even admired, yet seeing offers it no protection. It is a wonderfully disturbing way for Jones to introduce The Beaded Curtain’s deeper preoccupation: what it means to witness something, how much truth the witness actually possesses, and whether seeing creates any moral responsibility to act.
So, the book begins. With an act of witnessing and an act of killing.
But Jones immediately starts inter-cutting this account with
glimpses of his older sister, Pat Jones. The beautiful and doomed Huia and his
beautiful sister flicker alongside one another rather than forming a
straightforward comparison. The bird’s extinction and the eventual loss of Pat
Jones seem to inhabit adjacent chambers of memory.
![]() |
Lloyd Jones was at Schrödinger’s Books (5/11/2026) to discuss The Beaded Curtain with Louise Ward of The Bookshop Detectives. Photo: Tim Gruar. |
There's another angle, with Sheep, which appears to move into the everyday New Zealand landscape but actually extends the same moral question. Sheep recur later in Sheep II, alongside pieces with ominous titles such as Live shipment, The clothes of the Hiroshima dead, A history of indifference, A history of violence and Invitation to a slaughter.
Their accumulation reveals one of the book’s most unsettling
themes: we inhabit a violent world, and yet somehow we devise ways of
accommodating violence within ordinary life.
In one story, Invitation to a slaughter, Jones provocatively places the killing of animals alongside the industrialised killing of human beings. He isn't arguing that slaughtering a sheep and dropping an atomic bomb on civilians are morally equivalent. Rather, the juxtaposition asks how we comprehend, rationalise and distance ourselves from acts of violence. How do we manage violence in our lives without being overwhelmed by its presence?
That question leads inevitably to Hiroshima.
At a writers’ festival in Vancouver in 2011, Jones
encountered an exhibition of clothes belonging to victims of the atomic bomb,
among them a boy’s kimono, a suit and a silk dress. The experience lodged
permanently in his imagination. Back in rural Wairarapa, he began seeing the
shapes of absent bodies from those Hiroshima clothes in the landscape. Watching
film of the aircraft heading towards Hiroshima created another disturbing
connection. Jones, watching decades later, knows what is about to happen. The people
below do not. Looking across farmland produces a similarly uncomfortable
feeling: he knows what ultimately awaits the livestock; the animals do not.
Huia and Sheep therefore provide the grammar with which
to read much of The Beaded Curtain. The huia approaches without
understanding what is coming. Sheep exist without knowledge of their fate.
Hiroshima begins another morning while we already know what is approaching
through the sky.
The witness knows something the witnessed does not.
![]() |
| Lloyd Jones at Schrödinger’s Books Photo: Tim Gruar. |
It is hardly surprising that notebooks are fundamental to Jones’s practice. Back in 2002 he said that wherever he went, including buses, trams and walking, “I always have a pen and notebook with me”. More than two decades later, discussing The Beaded Curtain, he described the notebook as “an essential item”, something that obliges the writer to look more closely and attentively at the world.
That lifelong practice of noticing helps explain the
structure of this book. Jones says it took years to find its form. He even
experimented with writing in a book of blank musical staves, placing words and
phrases as a composer might place notes. He wanted observations “jammed up
against each other”, disappearing and resurfacing like musical motifs.
It isn't an entirely new technique for him. There is a
fascinating precedent in The Book of Fame, Jones’s multi-perspective
reimagining of the famous 1905–06 All Blacks tour. The “Originals” played 35
matches and lost only once, a 3–0 defeat to Wales at Cardiff Arms Park. That
match remains part of rugby mythology because All Black Bob Deans maintained
that he had scored a late try, although referee John Dallas ruled otherwise.
The Book of Fame already showed Jones experimenting
with shifting perspectives and collective consciousness rather than depending
upon a single authoritative witness. In The Beaded Curtain, that
technique has become even more fragmented: we keep swapping views, much as our
view through the moving curtain continually changes.
Family inevitably appears through those shifting beads.
Jones was the youngest of five children and considerably younger than his
siblings, an arrangement he believes helped turn him into an observer. His much
older brother was Sir Bob Jones, the flamboyant property investor and former
politician, whose success offered the young Lloyd Jones an extraordinary
glimpse of a life far beyond suburban Lower Hutt. Yet, in one story, it's a mix of that flamboyance. An opening when his brother gives the adolescent Jones a sheep and later helps to dispose of it in a paddock up the road. The memory for me is of the poor animal stuffed into the back of a sports car and chauffeured up the lanes to a new home where it's considered by the other wooly occupants as a rude interloper.
Just as important was Pat Jones, who was partnered with, and
later married, the brilliantly unconventional scientist and cartoonist Bob
Brockie. Jones lived with them as a teenager. Brockie knew birds, plants and
insects, collected butterflies, spoke Italian, played around with music and
could produce cartoons with apparently effortless satirical bite. Jones
remembers making Sicilian omelettes before school while dead hedgehogs awaiting
Brockie’s scientific attention occupied the refrigerator. Drawings of Sicilian
villages hung around the kitchen and, perhaps inevitably, Sicily became a
destination when Jones himself headed overseas at 21.
That influence seems to play out beautifully in The
Beaded Curtain. Brockie demonstrated that curiosity did not have to stay in
one lane, while Jones’s new book similarly moves without apology between
natural history, family, politics, landscape, violence, memory and art.
Pat Jones’s presence is more poignant. She was dying as her
brother moved towards completing the book, and Huia, despite opening it, was
among the later pieces he wrote. Jones has resisted describing the book simply
as a tribute to her. Rather, he has talked about witnessing his older sister’s
“splash in the world”.
That phrase gets close to the emotional core of the book. Love,
for Jones, can be an act of paying attention.
Witnessing becomes considerably more problematic when Jones
turns from personal memory towards history. One troubling example involves
Archibald Baxter, the New Zealand pacifist and conscientious objector who later
became the father of poet James K. Baxter. Following the introduction of
conscription, Archibald Baxter was arrested and in July 1917 was one of 14
resistant conscientious objectors forcibly put aboard the troopship Waitemata
and taken overseas. On the Western Front he endured Field Punishment No. 1, the
notorious “Crucifixion”, in which he was bound by his hands, knees and feet to
a post for up to four hours at a time.
But Jones is interested not merely in what happened to
Baxter; he is interested in what we can know happened.
In The Beaded Curtain, Jones raises the story of
Baxter being paraded through the streets of Dunedin before he was eventually
shipped overseas. There is no surviving documentation that definitively
establishes this particular episode. But for Jones, that absence becomes part
of the point. He says wartime accounts of such events were redacted or
censored, opening another of the book’s central questions: if an event is
witnessed but subsequently suppressed from the record, where does that leave
historical truth?
The uncertainty is important. Jones is not simply compiling history. He is investigating the sometimes treacherous space between experience, witness, memory and record.
Indeed, that ambiguity returns us to the very beginning of
the book. Buller witnesses the huia. Jones witnesses sheep. Someone sees
Baxter. Cameras eventually allow later generations to witness Hiroshima. Yet no
witness has the complete view.
This is why the beaded curtain is such a successful
organising image.
Jones himself says the book has two cornerstones: Hiroshima
and Berlin’s Memorial to the Murdered Jews of Europe. The latter exerted such a
pull that during periods living in Berlin he returned repeatedly, watching how
people moved through it. Hiroshima produces something fiercer. When his
publisher suggested the book contained “fury”, particularly around the atomic
bombing, Jones acknowledged that the fury had been with him for some time and
that there was “no shortage of things for it to attach itself to”.
Eventually, therefore, The Beaded Curtain becomes a
book about violence, truth and the moral difficulty of looking.
Its fragmented method will not suit everyone. Some
connections are deliberately elusive and others feel intensely personal. Yet
that is also its strength. Memory doesn't operate like a carefully indexed
archive. One picture summons another: huia becomes sister, sheep becomes
Hiroshima, Lower Hutt becomes Berlin, and private experience collides with
historical atrocity.
For the writer internationally associated with Mister Pip,
The Beaded Curtain feels less like a conventional late-career memoir
than an examination of the machinery operating behind a lifetime of writing.
Where did Lloyd Jones learn to look? Why do some images
refuse to leave him? Can witnessing take us closer to truth? What happens when
evidence has been removed? How do otherwise decent people accommodate violence?
And after we have witnessed something terrible, what responsibility do we
carry?
The curtain never finally opens. That is precisely the
point. Instead, the beads shift and something appears: Pat Jones, a huia, a
sheep awaiting slaughter, his wealthy brother’s sports car, Bob Brockie’s
gloriously eccentric household, Archibald Baxter tied to a post, the empty
clothing of someone killed at Hiroshima.
Then the beads close again.
Lloyd Jones doesn't pretend that the writer can see
everything. Truth itself may sometimes only be available in fragments. But the
writer, like the witness, has a responsibility to keep looking.
In a world astonishingly practised at violence, forgetting
and looking away, The Beaded Curtain asks us to look again.




.png)
Comments