REVIEW: Sovereignty - The case for Constitutional Transformation by Claire Charters (Bridget Williams Books)
Claire Charters reckons New Zealand's constitution doesn't just fail Māori, it fails the rest of us too. And she makes a pretty compelling case
But what if our constitutional foundations aren't quite as flash as we think?
That's the rather big question. And she doesn't muck around. While it's a bold claim, it's one she backs up with some fascinating history, examples and arguments about how our country is actually governed.
Before anyone starts worrying that this is going to be 170ish pages of lawyers arguing over commas, relax. This isn't an intimidating academic textbook. It's an accessible, thought-provoking look at how New Zealand operates, where our political authority comes from and whether the system we've inherited is really fit for purpose. You don't need to know your constitutional law from your elbow to follow the argument.
Charters is well qualified to take on the subject. She's Professor of Law at the University of Auckland, specialising in Indigenous peoples' rights, international law and constitutional transformation. Her iwi affiliations include Ngāti Whakaue, Tainui, Ngāti Tūwharetoa, Ngāti Tahu, Ngāti Whaoa and Ngāti Rehia. Her academic career has included work at the universities of Otago, New York and Cambridge, as well as involvement with the United Nations on Indigenous rights.
In other words, she knows her stuff, but thankfully she's not writing just for other academics.
So, who actually owns the keys to the place?
At the heart of the book is a pretty straightforward question: how did the Crown acquire the right to govern New Zealand, and was that acquisition ever legally legitimate?
Most of us grew up with a fairly simple version of the story. The Treaty of Waitangi was signed in 1840, the Crown established sovereignty, and the country gradually developed into the democracy we know today.
Charters reckons that version glosses over some rather important details.
She argues that the Crown's assertion of sovereignty in 1840 failed to satisfy the legal requirements of the time under three different systems: tikanga Māori, British law and international law.
Under Te Tiriti o Waitangi, Māori were guaranteed tino rangatiratanga – authority and self-determination over their lands, communities and affairs. The Crown's subsequent claim to complete governing authority, Charters argues, cannot simply be accepted as an unquestionable legal fact.
Put another way, just because the Crown took control doesn't necessarily mean it had the legal right to do so.
She is particularly critical of the way New Zealand's courts have largely avoided properly confronting the legality of the Crown's original assumption of sovereignty. Instead, the system has generally treated Crown authority as a settled matter.
For Charters, that's a pretty uncomfortable position for a country that likes to pride itself on the rule of law. If we're serious about the law, shouldn't we be prepared to examine the legal foundations of our own government?
And this isn't just ancient history gathering dust in the archives. The consequences are still playing out today in decisions about who holds power, whose laws are recognised and whose rights are protected.
Ok. Why should the rest of us care?
This is where Charters makes her most interesting argument.
New Zealand doesn't have one comprehensive written constitution like many other countries. Our constitutional arrangements are scattered across legislation, court decisions, historical documents and political conventions.
We've generally regarded this as flexible and practical. Charters sees some pretty serious weaknesses.
One of the biggest is parliamentary sovereignty. In simple terms, Parliament has enormous power to make and change laws, and our courts generally cannot strike down an Act of Parliament simply because it breaches fundamental rights or conflicts with Te Tiriti. And, as David Seymour tried to screw with recently, the principles of those rights. Claiming an unfounder legal assumption based on the myth of acceptance based on general acceptance it seems. And then, lets argue, some are less or more priveledged and others are left out of the acceptance bubble. Are you following all this?
That means protections many of us assume are guaranteed can be weakened or removed by a government with enough parliamentary support.
Charters points to some recent examples. Changes to the Oranga Tamariki Act removed a requirement for the ministry to give effect to Treaty principles and work in partnership with iwi and hapū. This happened despite a Waitangi Tribunal recommendation to abandon the changes.
She also discusses climate activist Mike Smith's legal action against major greenhouse gas emitters. The Supreme Court allowed the case to proceed in 2024, but the Government subsequently announced plans to legislate to prevent climate claims of this kind.
For Charters, these examples highlight a worrying problem. If governments can use their parliamentary numbers to undermine protections or restrict people's ability to challenge decisions, what exactly is protecting us?
Today it might be Māori rights or environmental protections. Tomorrow it could be minority rights, democratic freedoms or something that directly affects you and your family.
That's why she says the constitution fails everyone, not just Māori. A system that leaves fundamental rights vulnerable to political convenience isn't particularly reassuring for anyone.
It's a bit like having a front door with an impressive-looking lock that the government can simply decide to remove whenever it feels like it.
What would she do differently? You ask.
Thankfully, Charters isn't just pointing out the holes in the boat and leaving everyone to bail out the water. She has some ideas about how we might build something better.
She looks overseas for inspiration, particularly at Mexico, whose constitutional reforms have made significant advances in recognising Indigenous rights and self-determination.
The important point is that Indigenous communities need more than a seat at the consultation table. They need genuine authority over their own affairs, institutions, communities and development.
She also draws on research from Harvard University's Project on Indigenous Governance and Development, which shows that communities tend to achieve better economic, social and environmental outcomes when they have meaningful control over their own futures.
That's an important point. Recognising Māori rights isn't simply about addressing historical grievances or ticking a box. There are practical benefits for the whole country when communities have the power to make decisions that affect them.
Charters proposes a fundamental rethink of our constitutional arrangements, with several key ingredients.
First, Te Tiriti o Waitangi needs to be recognised as a genuine constitutional foundation, rather than something governments can acknowledge when it suits them and sideline when it doesn't.
Second, Māori need meaningful tino rangatiratanga – real authority to manage their own affairs, develop their own institutions and exercise tikanga.
Third, fundamental human rights need stronger protection. They shouldn't be so easily overridden by whichever government happens to have the numbers in Parliament.
Fourth, tikanga Māori needs a proper place in our legal and constitutional system. Māori law shouldn't simply be treated as a cultural consideration within a system built almost entirely around English legal traditions.
And finally, she wants a new constitutional relationship that works for all New Zealanders, recognising the rights and interests of Māori and tangata Tiriti alike.
Importantly, this isn't about swapping one group with unchecked power for another. It's about sharing authority more fairly and creating a system with greater legitimacy, accountability and respect.
Is it all a bit ambitious?
Well, yes. Changing the constitutional foundations of a country is hardly a weekend DIY project.
There will inevitably be questions about how such a transformation would work in practice, what institutions would look like and how public confidence could be maintained. Some people will worry about uncertainty and the potential consequences for existing arrangements.
Those are fair questions, and any serious constitutional change would need plenty of public discussion, negotiation and participation.
But that's no reason to avoid the conversation.
One of the book's strengths is that Charters doesn't treat constitutional reform as something only lawyers, politicians and academics should worry about. She makes it clear that these arrangements affect everyday life. They determine who gets heard, who makes decisions, how governments are held accountable and whether our rights mean anything when the political pressure comes on.
She also challenges our comfortable assumption that New Zealand is already doing pretty well compared with the rest of the world. We might like to think we're progressive, but are the foundations of our democracy actually living up to that reputation?
It's a question worth asking.
The verdict
Sovereignty is an important, timely and surprisingly accessible book that deserves a wider audience than the usual constitutional-law crowd.
Charters challenges some deeply held assumptions about New Zealand's history and the way we're governed, but she does so in a way that invites people into the conversation rather than shutting them out with academic waffle.
You don't have to agree with every argument to appreciate the importance of asking these questions. And you certainly don't need a law degree to understand that a system which allows governments to weaken fundamental protections should concern us all.
Ultimately, this is about what sort of country we want to be. Do we simply accept the constitutional arrangements we've inherited, or do we have the courage to build something that better reflects our history, our people and the values we claim to stand for?
Charters makes a strong case that constitutional transformation isn't just a Māori issue. It's about fairness, democracy, accountability and the future of Aotearoa.
At 176 pages, it's a manageable read, even for those who normally run a mile at the mention of constitutional law.
My recommendation? Give it a go. It's a good deal more interesting than the title might suggest.
And perhaps it's time we stopped admiring the wallpaper, took a proper look under the bonnet and asked whether the foundations of the house are actually up to scratch.
![]() |
| Claire Charters (BWB) |
Rotorua-born and connected through whakapapa to Ngāti Whakaue, Tainui, Tūwharetoa, Ngāti Tahu, Ngāti Whaoa and Ngāti Rehia, Claire Charters has taken a distinctly Aotearoa perspective on Indigenous rights to some of the world’s most influential legal and political forums. Her academic path has carried her from Ōtākou Whakaihu Waka, the University of Otago, where she earned an LLB (Hons) and BA, to an LLM at New York University and a PhD at Cambridge University. Today, as a professor at Waipapa Taumata Rau, the University of Auckland, and co-director of Te Puna Rangahau o Te Wai Ariki, the New Zealand Centre for Indigenous Peoples and the Law, she works at the point where Indigenous sovereignty, constitutional law and international human rights meet. But hers is not a career confined to lecture theatres and legal scholarship. Charters was involved in negotiations on the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, advised the President of the UN General Assembly, served within the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, and became both a board member and Chair of the UN Voluntary Fund for Indigenous Peoples. In 2023–24, she returned that global experience to the local arena as Rongomau Taketake, Indigenous Governance Partner at Te Kāhui Tika Tangata, the New Zealand Human Rights Commission.


Comments