REVIEW: Captain Cook and the Unsettled Afterlives of Empire - Tony Ballantyne (Bridget Williams Books)
Tony Ballantyne’s Captain Cook and the Unsettled Afterlives of Empire is one of those history books that feels less like a biography and more like a long, uneasy conversation New Zealand keeps having with itself. It’s literary, carefully argued, and quietly provocative—never shouting, but constantly nudging you to notice how Cook keeps reappearing whenever the country argues about who it is. Ballantyne starts with cultural shock tactics. Sort of. One of the most striking threads in Ballantyne’s postcolonial section is the way he situates New Zealand’s debates within wider Pacific currents. Haunani‑Kay Trask’s late‑1980s visit to Aotearoa—where she challenged celebratory narratives of Cook and empire—becomes a kind of hinge moment. On the prime show ‘Holmes’, Trask’s unapologetic framing of Cook as a coloniser and symbol of dispossession collided with a television culture that still treated him as a largely heroic figure. The outrage from many Pākehā viewers, and the show’s ...