REVIEW: Front Row Seat - Juliet A. Gerrard (Auckland University Press)


Imagine being the person whose job it is to walk into a room full of politicians during a pandemic and say: "Well, the science suggests..." before watching every pair of eyes search for a loophole.

That, in essence, is the world of Dame Juliet Gerrard's engaging, revealing and often surprisingly funny memoir, Front Row Seat: How Science Can (and Can't) Shape Public Decision-Making.

For six years, Gerrard occupied one of the most unusual jobs in New Zealand. As Chief Science Advisor to three prime ministers, Jacinda Ardern, Chris Hipkins and Christopher Luxon, she stood at the uncomfortable intersection of evidence, politics, media, public panic and, occasionally, reality itself.

This isn't a political memoir in the traditional sense. Nobody is settling scores. There are no dramatic Cabinet betrayals, no anonymous briefings, no revelations involving coded text messages and late-night karaoke. Instead, Gerrard offers something rarer: a backstage pass to the machinery of government from the perspective of someone whose primary job was to ask awkward questions and insist on evidence before action.

And what a six years it was. Most public servants would consider surviving a once-in-a-century pandemic sufficient career material. Gerrard somehow ended up with COVID-19, the Christchurch mosque attacks, the Whakaari/White Island disaster, the occupation of Parliament grounds, debates over 5G, genetic engineering, cannabis reform, food waste and plastics all packed into a single term. Less a job description, more a prolonged stress test.

One of the book's greatest strengths is that Gerrard never pretends science can magically solve everything. In fact, much of Front Row Seat is devoted to explaining why it can't.

Scientists, she reminds us, are excellent at estimating risk, evaluating evidence and understanding uncertainty. Politicians, on the other hand, must also worry about public opinion, economics, culture, values, elections and the minor inconvenience of people disagreeing with each other. The result is a fascinating exploration of the tension between what science can tell us and what governments must ultimately decide.

The Jacinda Ardern years naturally loom large. Readers hoping for intimate political gossip may be disappointed, but those interested in how science informed policy decisions during some of New Zealand's most challenging moments will find plenty to savour. Gerrard writes about standing close to decision-making processes during crises where there were no perfect answers, only varying degrees of uncertainty. During COVID, questions such as how quickly the virus might spread or how many people could die were not abstract academic exercises. They were real questions requiring real answers under immense pressure.

What makes the book particularly enjoyable is Gerrard herself. Many science communicators suffer from a fatal condition known as 'Chronic Lecture Voice'. Gerrard does not. Her warmth, wit and self-awareness repeatedly shine through. Even endorsements for the book note how strongly her humour comes across on the page.

She has an enviable ability to explain complex topics without making readers feel as though they have accidentally wandered into a first-year university seminar. Whether discussing artificial intelligence in healthcare, vaccine modelling or plastic bags, she consistently translates complexity into accessible language.

There is also something deeply reassuring about Gerrard's approach to expertise. In an era when everyone with a social-media account seems convinced they know more than immunologists, volcanologists and epidemiologists combined, Front Row Seat serves as a reminder that genuine expertise remains useful. Not infallible, but useful.

AUP Publicity Photo

Perhaps the funniest aspect of the book is the sheer absurdity of some of the issues science advisors find themselves addressing. One moment you're discussing pandemic modelling. The next you're fielding questions about 5G towers, cannabis legalisation, gene editing or public fears surrounding emerging technologies. Gerrard repeatedly demonstrates that scientific advice is only partly about science. The rest involves understanding people, and people are gloriously unpredictable.

If there is a weakness, it is that readers chasing hard political drama may occasionally wish for a little more blood on the floor. Gerrard is generous, measured and diplomatic to a fault. She is far more interested in systems than personalities. That's arguably the book's integrity showing, but a few readers may find themselves yearning for one chapter titled 'Things I Wanted To Say But Couldn't'. Unfortunately, science advisors are generally more mature than reviewers.

Still, that's a minor complaint. What Front Row Seat ultimately delivers is a fascinating account of modern government under pressure. Gerrard's stories reveal how evidence travels through institutions, how decisions are made under uncertainty, and how difficult it is to separate facts from politics once a crisis becomes public.

Most importantly, she reminds us that science is not a magic eight-ball. It won't tell governments exactly what to do. What it can do is make sure they're at least arguing about reality.

In today's world, that feels like a surprisingly ambitious goal. 

Smart, humane, wonderfully personal and 'real' - and surprisingly funny, Front Row Seat turns six tumultuous years of public service into a compelling exploration of science, politics and human nature. Gerrard proves that evidence may not always win the argument, but it deserves a seat at the table. And after reading this book, you'll be glad she had a front-row seat when it did.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

EVENT: VerbCrawl is back - For One Night Only - November 14th 2026!

Noelle McCarthy: from Grand to Stakes: An interview about mothers, memory, addiction and the books that help us make sense of ourselves

WOMAD: The World Of Words Programme is announced

INTERVIEW: Daniel Vernon Draws Prime Ministers, Fronts a Punk Band and Wrestles Māui

INTERVIEW: Asher Emanuel, Author of The Valley: Crime and Punishment in a New Zealand City (Bridget Williams Books)