REVIEW: The Collector: Thomas Cheeseman and The Making of The Auckland Museum - Andrew McKay and Richard Wolfe (Massey University Press)
This wonderfully a vivid, scholarly, yet accessible biography opens up the world of the Victorian collector, inspired by nature and a quest for knowledge. This wonderful book charts the life of one such man, one of Aotearoa's most influential naturalists. It's both a portrait of Auckland Museum's founding director and of Thomas Cheeseman himself. It delves into the cultural history of Auckland Museum and how it evolved from a modest curiosity cabinet to one of the leading scientific institution in the Southern Hemisphere.
At the heart of the book lies the transformation of Auckland Museum under Cheeseman’s leadership, from a “shed of curiosities” into a respected institution with international connections.
Auckland Museum was founded in 1852, beginning life in a small two-room farm cottage in Grafton. Over the following decades it grew steadily, moving into larger premises in central Auckland as its collections expanded. In 1929, subscriptions raised by Aucklanders in remembrance of their war dead funded the construction of the grand neoclassical building on Pukekawa hill in the Auckland Domain, which remains its home today. Since then, the Auckland War Memorial Museum has become one of New Zealand’s most important cultural institutions, housing millions of objects and serving both as a place of discovery and as a memorial to those who served in wars.
Thomas Frederick Cheeseman (1845–1923) was one of New Zealand’s most influential botanists and museum directors, remembered for shaping the Auckland Museum and for his landmark contributions to the study of New Zealand’s flora. Born in 1845, Hull, Yorkshire, Cheeseman emigrated with his family to Auckland in 1853. He was educated locally at Parnell Grammar School and St John’s College. That's where his fascination, and later obsession, started and by his early twenties he was publishing scientific papers, corresponding with Charles Darwin about unique indigenous orchids and establishing himself as a leading authority in colonial scientific circles.
Cheeseman’s career was defined by his dual passions: botany and museum work. In 1874 he was appointed curator of the Auckland Museum, a position he held for nearly fifty years until his death in 1923. Under his leadership, the museum grew from a modest collection into a respected institution with international connections. He expanded its holdings across natural history, ethnology, and zoology, and professionalized its operations, ensuring its place as a civic and educational cornerstone.
And, on the other hand, as a leading botanist, Cheeseman described over 130 plant species and three genera, with sixteen species from New Zealand and Rarotonga named in his honor. But his most enduring work was The Manual of the New Zealand Flora (1906, revised 1925), which remained the authoritative reference for decades. He also published Illustrations of the New Zealand Flora (1914), and his herbarium eventually numbered around 10,000 specimens. Cheeseman’s botanical abbreviation “Cheeseman” is still used in scientific citations, even today.Cheeseman’s work reflects the Victorian drive to classify, catalogue, and understand the natural world. His collections helped shape New Zealand’s scientific identity, while his correspondence with figures such as Charles Darwin and the Hookers of Kew Gardens situated Auckland Museum within global scientific networks.
Cheeseman’s reputation extended internationally. He corresponded with leading scientists of his era, was elected a Fellow of the Linnean Society of London, and received its prestigious gold medal in 1923. He also served as president of the New Zealand Institute in 1911 and was awarded the Hector Memorial Medal in 1918.
Despite his achievements, Cheeseman was known for his cautious conservatism. He resisted some innovations in museum practice, preferring careful expansion over radical change. Yet his dedication and vision ensured that Auckland Museum became a cornerstone of New Zealand’s scientific and cultural life.
Cheeseman married Rosetta “Rose” Keesing in 1889, and they had two children. He died in Auckland on 15 October 1923, aged 77. His legacy endures in the museum he helped build, the flora he catalogued, and the scientific networks he nurtured.
McKay and Wolfe have used a combination of narrative flair and studious academic rigor to build a picture that honours and celebrate Cheeseman. With attention to details, McKay draws on his doctoral research into Cheeseman. Wolfe brings decades of experience as a cultural historian and curator. Together they trace Cheeseman’s journey from his birth in England in 1845, through his emigration to New Zealand at the age of eight, to his lifelong fascination with plants and his eventual career in botany and museum work.Cheeseman’s work reflects the Victorian drive to classify, catalogue, and understand the natural world. His collections helped shape New Zealand’s scientific identity, while his correspondence with figures such as Charles Darwin and the Hookers of Kew Gardens situated Auckland Museum within global scientific networks.
The book is full of photos and illustrations from the period, which give it real gravitas. There are photos of exhibits, drawings of fauna and paintings. There are a number of images of the Museum and its displays at the time. and a fabulous image of conserver and taxidermist Louis Griffin at work in the basement of the museum in 1909, surrounded by stuffed and preserve animals and birds ready for the display cabinets. There are also interesting facsimiles such as a letter from Andreas Reischek to Cheeseman discussing the procuring of native birds for his collection - which is something completely reviled and banned today. It shows the Victorian attitude of mixing collector obsession with scientific enquiry.
Speaking of letters, there's a copy of Cheeseman's letter to Darwin in 1873. Coming across that must have been an incredible experience. And is the letter by Joseph Dalton Hooker, 1867, director of Kew Gardens, who corresponded to enquire about Cheeseman's potential discovery of a native variety of orchid. This was his pivotal moment, bringing enough prestige and respect to continue in the Victorian botany world.
The book’s strengths lie in its rich detail and balanced narrative. It is meticulously researched, drawing on archival material, correspondence, and institutional records. McKay and Wolfe avoid hagiography, presenting Cheeseman as both visionary and pragmatic, occasionally conservative but always dedicated. They situate his work within broader debates about colonialism, science, and museum culture, making the biography relevant beyond New Zealand. The publication itself, from Massey University Press, is enriched by photographs, illustrations, and archival images that bring the story to life.
| This is a page from The Collector (Click to browse) |
Some might be a little bit intimidated by the density of detail but this quickly gives way to an appreciation of the times and the challenges he and his contemporaries faced. And appropriately, there is the important questions about colonial collecting practices and how they marginalized indigenous knowledge and tikanga. There was something of an assumed superiority, despite us now knowing that Māori knowledge of the natural world is extensive way beyond that of the Victorian imagination. A stark reminder that our relationship with institutions is complex and often confronting. On one side we appreciate their studious work. On the other, we are distinctly uncomfortable about the way they went about collecting and cataloguing fauna and flora, and wildlife.
This particular biography is much more than just about one man. It holds a lens up to academia, and how museums operate in their purist fashion, for the pursuit of knowledge, almost in a vacuum, isolated from people and culture, and time itself defining identity and power power in colonial societies. Dangerously, museums and their discoveries informed political thinking. That still applies today, unfortunately. This is a problem to manage very carefully. Cheeseman remains a fascinating figure, bridging the local and global science community. He leaves us with a legacy and a volume of knowledge that defines and challenges both the Auckland and every other Museum in the country - how to define their purpose and kaupapa going forward. What is their purpose. One thing I do know: we must fight to preserve museums as pataka of knowledge and seats of enquiry - even if they reveal inconvenient truths about ourselves, our world and our history.
A quick note about the authors
Andrew McKay holds a PhD in art history from the University of Auckland and was a Professional Teaching Fellow in the university’s art history department.
Richard Wolfe is an Associate Emeritus of the Auckland War Memorial Museum and from 1978 to 1997 was Curator of Display.

Comments