REVIEW: Chris Knox: Not Given Lightly - Craig Robinson (Auckland University Press)
Everybody has a story about Chris Knox. I you went to university in the 1980’s and 1990’s then it was almost a guarantee that you’d see him bouncing around the Victoria University Orientation week stages in daggy shorts and jandals – even in the heart of winter! As a regular on Radio Active, Pōneke’s student radio, I’d frequently have Chris behind the mic promoting his latest album, gig or project. He was always welcoming, quirky, ad-hoc and unpredictable. Back then we were super conscious of swearing and profanity on air (due to the tenous nature of the student license agreement). Keeping Chris in line was always a challenge, being a ‘free speaker’. But it wasn’t just his voice and music that was a permanent fixture on campus. His cartoons appeared not only in the Listener (which we devoured up at the library) or student mags like Salient but also on gig posters around campus.
At Colin Morris Records in Willis St. we’d swoop in to
collect up the latest releases from the Flying Nun stable, including Toy Love
and Tall Dwarfs singles. They were beautifully ‘dinky’. Photocopied,
black‘n’white art. DIY to the max. Often personalised and hand drawn,
handwritten art. They were difficult to read because Chris always jammed on so
such incredible information. Plus, there were in jokes and odd little ‘brain
farts’ that sometimes I thought only he could decipher. You could go back again
and again to find more little references. It was a veritable treasure hunt on a
simple 45 single cover then there was the music itself. None of the songs even approximated
the highly condensed qualities of the big studios. Chris would create music
with guitars, mic stands, keyboards, cocoa tins, spoons, hammers or whatever
came to hand. And the recordings were raw and frayed. Beautifully shabby!
When I think back, the 80’s was such an explosive period –
modern technology, DIY punk and the growth of stadium mega concerts like those
of U2 and Iron Maiden. (who even had their own plane, piloted by the band’s
lead singer!). In Aotearoa, at the end of the 70’s we were all so far
undisturbed by the impending cultural tidal waves that were about to crash over
us. Everything was brown, beige and boring!
My own cultural awareness only came during the school
holidays when I heard Foetus Productions and Tall Dwarfs on my Walkman radio
whilst I sat up on the top floor of my dad’s warehouse, counting out grommets
and washers from enormous bulk packs and separating them into tiny bags for
on-sale. It was a total revelation to know that there was music beyond the
Eagles and Pat Benatar. There was experimentation and quirky, glitchy,
abrasive, challenging, oddball music for outsiders like me. And I loved it. Is
still do!
In ‘Not Given Lightly’, Craig Robertson delivers a
monumental, deeply researched, and emotionally resonant life story of Chris
Knox—one of Aotearoa’s most influential and iconoclastic cultural figures.
Spanning over 450 pages and 16 years in the making, this life story is as exhaustive
as it is intimate, capturing the mischief, spirit, and struggle of a man who
helped shape New Zealand’s alternative music and art scenes.
Robertson, who’s a US-based academic (and brother of former
New Zealand Finance Minister Grant Robertson), like Matthew Goody (Needles and
Plastic) brings some scholarly rigor, and outsider’s view and his own personal
passion to the project. Robertson’s background is media studies. But he also
has his own roots back to Ōtepoti (Dunedin). He once penned a thesis on the
“Dunedin Sound”. Dig it out from the Otago archives one day. Given all that, I
think he’s pretty well qualified to sensitively dissect Knox’s complex life and
legacy. Albeit that Chris is still with us and may have his own thoughts on the
publication once it surfaces.
Chris Knox’s story is one of fierce independence, unrelenting
creativity, innovation and the complete deconstruction of anything normal or
ordinary. From his younger days growing up in Invercargill to his role as a
leader of chaos in the Dunedin punk scene, Chris emerged as a singular voice in
New Zealand’s cultural landscape. As we know, he fronted iconic indie acts like
The Enemy, Toy Love, and Tall Dwarfs. Each played a crucial role in the
formation of the Flying Nun Records ‘sound’ — that of a lo-fi, DIY aesthetic,
brought about by necessity and no.8 wire mentality, and one that’ll influence a
multitude of musicians and generations both here and overseas.
| Photo: Alec Bathgate |
Knox’s home studio, centered around a TEAC A-3340S 4-track
reel-to-reel recorder (https://www.undertheradar.co.nz/news/11821/Heres-Five-Chris-Knoxs-TEAC-4-Track-Tape-Machine.utr).
It became the ‘crucible’ for many of Flying Nun’s early releases. With this
modest setup, he captured not only his own music but also helped shape the
sound of bands like The Clean, The Chills, and The Verlaines. His approach to
recording—raw, immediate, and unfiltered—was revolutionary, embodying the punk
ethos of accessibility and authenticity.
According to Robertson, the Punk Awakening for Chris came
after watching iconic music journo Dylan Taite’s TV
documentary on the Sex Pistols. Seeing people who were “as talentless musically
as him” being adored for their raw energy, Knox realized he didn’t need
technical skill to make music—just passion and nerve.
In his early days with The Enemy, Chris became infamous for cutting himself on stage. One time, he did this with a bottle. It didn’t hurt but looked very effective, he’d reckoned. Well, he claimed it didn’t hurt until the next morning, when he had to peel the blood-stuck sheets off his arm. It was all part of his mission to provoke and challenge audiences.
‘Not Given Lightly’ became the title track of Chris’ life story – and his most infamous track. It began as a joke. He stumbled upon a doo-wop chord progression which he’d thought so ‘corny’ that his only option was to “write a love track” —something he’d said, at the time, was a genre he’d always avoided. But as he strummed, deeply personal lyrics emerged. In the end it was the purest dedication to his partner Barbara Ward. He later described the track as “fucking cute” and admitted it made him giggle. I’d wish I knew that when I chose it for my wedding song! But I still love it, anyway.
From Indie Anthem to TV Ad: In a twist that surprised many fans, 'Not Given Lightly' was later used in a Vogel’s Bread commercial, introducing Knox’s heartfelt anthem to a new generation. The ad sparked debate about commercialism and authenticity but also reaffirmed the track’s emotional resonance and cultural reach.
Knox thought the finished track was “fucking cute”—it made him giggle, he told RNZ in 1998. But he had finally written a love track he could live with. Barbara Ward, the subject of the track, also came to appreciate it. While other Knox tracks had explored aspects of their relationship, “Not Given Lightly” became a snapshot of a particular moment—honest, specific, and emotionally resonant.
The track was unlike anything he had written with Tall
Dwarfs, where lyrics were often political or surreal, and always collaborative.
On his solo records, Knox had the freedom to be more autobiographical, more
direct, and more emotionally vulnerable.
Flying Nun saw the potential in 'Not Given Lightly' and
published it as a 12-inch single. Even TVNZ got behind it, offering Knox a crew
to shoot a music video. He kept it simple: two takes of him singing directly to
the camera, gradually pulling back to reveal a group of friends. He edited the
two versions together, cutting on the beat. The result, he felt, was “just
okay,” but it aired on the music video show 'CV'.
Despite the support, the track didn’t chart in New Zealand.
Knox had hoped mainstream radio might embrace it, but he wasn’t surprised when
they didn’t. Still, he included some of his best work from Songs for Cleaning
Guppies on the B-side, hoping to show new listeners another side of his music.
Ever the realist, he told Metro’s Garth Cartwright that while he could polish
the track to make it more commercial, “what would be the point?” He wanted to
affect people without conforming to industry expectations.
In Australia, the reception was warmer. With more diverse
radio formats, 'Not Given Lightly' received enough airplay to suggest it could
have been a hit with the right push. Knox toured the country in 1990, playing
five shows in major cities and meeting with Mushroom Records, Flying Nun’s new
Australian partner. Though wary of major labels, Knox got along with the
Mushroom team, who quickly recognized his promotional energy and legacy status.
The tour generated strong press, especially around 'Not
Given Lightly.' One Brisbane reviewer called it “one of the greatest love songs
ever written.” Live reviews were mixed but intrigued. Sydney’s Drum Media
described Knox as someone who, during an encore, polled the audience for a
topic and improvised a track about masturbation. Time Off called him “slightly
loopy, a mite too intelligent for his own good, and rather talented,”
concluding:
On June 11, 2009, Chris Knox suffered a debilitating stroke at his home in Grey Lynn, Auckland. The stroke left him with significant impairments, including loss of speech and paralysis on his right side. Despite this, Knox’s creative spirit endured. Ever the soldier, he re-taught himself to draw again, this time with his left hand and continued to engage with music and art producing a piece virtually every day (according to his dialogue in the new Shane Carter bio-pic ‘Life In One Chord’).
In response, the global music community rallied around him. The result was the benefit compilation album ‘Stroke: Songs for Chris Knox’, published in November 2009. The double album features 36 tracks—covers of Knox’s tracks by a stellar lineup of artists from New Zealand and abroad, including Bic Runga, Jeff Mangum (Neutral Milk Hotel), Yo La Tengo, The Mountain Goats, Bill Callahan, Bonnie “Prince” Billy, The Chills, The Bats, The Verlaines, David Kilgour, Don McGlashan, Shayne Carter, and Pavement.
The album also includes two new instrumental tracks by Knox himself—'Nappin’ in Lapland’ and ‘Sunday Song’—captured post-stroke, showcasing his continued artistic vitality despite immense physical challenges.
“Chris Knox is an acquired taste in that you have to listen
to one of his songs to acquire it. Long live the godfather.”
Knox was never just a musician. He was also a cartoonist,
film reviewer, and cultural critic, contributing regularly to The Listener and
The New Zealand Herald. His comic strip Max Media ran weekly from 1987 until
his stroke in 2009, offering biting satire and commentary on New Zealand
society. He also edited the underground comic anthology Jesus on a Stick,
further cementing his place in the country’s alternative art scene.
In the late 1980s, Knox began crafting his solo material at
home, often with just a single barre chord and a guitar. Songwriting was not a
daily ritual—it came in bursts. He would sit in his front room or at the piano
in the hallway and see what happened. Sometimes months would pass between
writing sessions.
He described track writing as a physical process. In an
interview with Russell Baillie of the NZ Herald, Knox said: “It’s just feeling
your shoulders flop around and letting your mind feel a bit soggy and your
fingers go where they want to go – that generally seems to be the best results
and things that come quickly tend to be better. If you have to actually work on
something it sounds like it’s been worked on.”
He valued immediacy and spontaneity, often letting the sound
of words guide his lyrics. By the second or third verse, he’d usually discover
what the track was about—then go back and tweak the earlier lines, but only
slightly. The goal was to preserve the natural flow and honesty of the moment.
Thus, ‘Not Given Lightly’, the book, is more than a life
story; it’s a chronicle of a cultural movement. The book delves deep into the
student radio scene, into Orientation gigs, and the rise and rise of the ‘Dunedin
Sound’, situating Knox within a broader context of New Zealand’s post-punk and
indie renaissance. Robertson’s meticulous attention to detail, supported by
plenty of interviews, archival research, and personal anecdotes. There are an
incredible wealth of cartoons, flyers and posters from Chris’ collection and
others, as well. Many times, you’ll read a chapter and then go back again to
peruse this ephemera a second and third time. No doubt, this is a definitive
account of an era and a man that reshaped our artistic identity.
When reading this book, take a moment to understand the
efforts put in, this is a labour of love, not some quick knock of fan book. In
a flood of recent Flying Nun related titles this one stands out for its sheer persistence.
I took Robertson over 16 years to complete – approved to proceed by Mr Knox only
just before he had the stroke in 2009.
‘Not Given Lightly’ is nothing short of a towering
achievement. It’s much more than just a breezy read. The density of content can be overwhelming,
but any fan of Chris Knox, Flying Nun, or Aotearoa’s cultural history will
immediately think differently. They will call it an essential text. It is a testament
to art, independence, and an anti-corporate approach. In an age of Spotify and Netflix, Chris Knox’s
work is so very much needed. It is the grass roots, the weeds that grow under
the feet of the major banal landscape of the conglomerate media. It is the
original push against the pricks. Chris Knox refuses to lay down. Read this
book and you will know why.

Comments